Why South Korea Is Sending $8 Million In Food Aid To North Korea

Jun 9, 2019
Originally published on June 9, 2019 10:15 pm

South Korea last week approved $8 million in food aid to North Korea, in response to what U.N. agencies say are the worst harvests there in a decade and severe food shortages affecting 40% of the North's population.

Despite the South Korean government's insistence on separating the aid from politics, the donation is widely seen as having the political goal of improving inter-Korean relations. With nuclear negotiations with the U.S. in limbo, South Korea is eager to nudge the North to return to the negotiating table — and humanitarian aid is one way to do that. Seoul was quick to point out that U.N. sanctions targeting the North's nuclear programs allow for humanitarian assistance and that the Trump administration is on board with it.

Even though North Korea requested the aid from international aid organizations and South Korean food will be distributed through those groups, Pyongyang was not impressed with the donation. It called the gesture — the first from Seoul since 2015 and the first under the administration of President Moon Jae-In — "non-essential" to ties between the two Koreas.

Aid agencies and politicians often trot out a Ronald Reagan quote: "A hungry child knows no politics." The idea is that nobody wants civilians to starve, even though their rulers' policies may be responsible for that hunger. And so governments and aid agencies must deliver humanitarian assistance.

The donations will be delivered through the World Food Programme and UNICEF. They will include nutritious food and medicine for infants, children and mothers at hospitals, nurseries and orphanages.

But the aid carries risks. One is that the aid is based on incomplete or inaccurate information. Another is that the aid will be diverted away from the intended recipients. In addition, the money a regime saves on buying food may be used on weapons. And the aid may delay reforms and perpetuate a system that distributes food inequitably.

To determine what kind of aid is needed, in April, teams from the U.N. Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), and the World Food Programme (WFP) fanned out across 12 counties in 6 of North Korea's 9 provinces to assess whether the country has enough food. (A similar survey was conducted last November). They spoke to farmers and officials and visited grain stores and nursery schools. That's not easy in North Korea, where aid agencies' access is often restricted.

The survey found that abnormally high temperatures, drought in some areas and flooding in others severely reduced the 2018 fall harvest of grains including rice, wheat and soybeans, leading to food insecurity for 10.1 millionof North Korea's 25.5 million people. North Korea's government is calling the droughts the worst in nearly four decades.

That's not nearly as bad as the mid-1990s, when up to 3.5 million people starved to death, largely due to economic mismanagement and the loss of Soviet support following the collapse of the USSR. But the survey did find that the country will have a shortage of 1.36 million metric tons of food.

Most North Koreans get food from government rations of basic foodstuffs such as rice, and those rations were cut down to 300 grams (approximately 10.6 ounces) per person, per day, compared to 380 grams (approximately 13.4 ounces) over the same period last year.

"When we were talking to household members especially with housewives, they were always reporting an incredibly low consumption of proteins," recalls Mario Zappacosta, a Rome-based FAO senior economist who co-led the survey in North Korea.

Meat, fish and eggs are rare in many North Koreans' diets. Many survive on rice or potatoes and kimchi, a spicy fermented cabbage dish. "There is a really poor and monotonous diet. This [finding] was really remarkable," says Zappacosta in a phone interview.

The international sanctions imposed by the U.N. Security Council and the U.S. in 2006, in response to North Korea's nuclear weapons testing, also have an effect. Although they are aimed at the North's military, not civilians, they make it hard to get machine parts and gas needed for efficient mechanized farming.

"With the reduced availability of fuel, we saw people using oxen, but also doing [ploughing] by hand," Zappacosta says.

Besides government rations, food is also distributed through networks of farmers' markets, and this was a blind spot in the survey, as the teams could not get access to those markets.

"Market visits are highly recommended to fill this information gap in future assessments," the survey report said.

But Zappacosta says findings were cross-checked against other data, such as satellite photos of farmland, and while there might have been a small margin of error, as for the "order of magnitude, we're quite confident."

Zappacosta notes that the WFP does monitor the distribution of food aid to ensure that it's reaching its intended recipients. And this is something that donors insist on. But he describes his own agency as a "technical institution" that avoids making policy recommendations or prescribing reforms.

Benjamin Katzeff Silberstein, a fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute and editor of the blog NKEconwatch, which follows the North Korean economy,notes that while the food situation in North Korea looks bad, it comes following a decade of increasing harvests and agricultural yields. These are due in part to limited agricultural reforms launched by Kim Jong Un.

"Farmers getting stronger incentives, being able to decide more about their own production, getting to keep more of what they farm — these things have almost certainly played a role in making agricultural production go up," he says.

Silberstein argues that the food shortages are less about how much food is produced than about how it's distributed. And the distribution, he says, favors Pyongyang, where politically loyal elites can now nosh at a growing number of Western-style cafes and fast food outlets.

"North Korea's food shortages aren't about external shocks from the weather, or from sanctions. They're about a system. That's it," he says.

Silberstein adds that the international community has sent the North food aid for some two decades — but food shortages "are going to keep happening as long as fundamental changes aren't put into place."

Food shortages are also due to the government's spending priorities, Silberstein says. Despite the famine, Pyongyang has money for vanity projects, like beach and ski resorts, and of course, weapons systems.

"If you can manufacture nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles clearly you can import enough food to make up for the shortfall in the harvest. There is no doubt about it."

Silberstein also points to the government's longstanding policy of trying to be self-sufficient in agriculture. That's unwise, he says, as the mountainous country has very little arable land, and would be better off exporting manufactured goods, and using the earned money to import food.

Clarification : 6/08/19

A previous version of this story referred to kimchi as a "Chinese cabbage dish." It is best known as a fermented food made with cabbage, often of the Chinese variety. But it is a Korean dish.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

North Korea has had one of the worst harvests in a decade. Millions are not getting enough to eat. The biggest worry is families with young children. NPR's Anthony Kuhn reports from Seoul that foreign donors are trying to assess food needs before they send in aid. But nothing is easy when working in the most isolated country in the world.

ANTHONY KUHN, BYLINE: The first challenge aid agencies face is this.

MARIO ZAPPACOSTA: To get information in North Korea is very difficult.

KUHN: That's Mario Zappacosta, a Rome-based economist with the UN Food and Agriculture Organization.

ZAPPACOZTA: So even to have information from 12 counties can be seen as a remarkable achievement.

KUHN: This spring, he and other UNFAO and World Food Programme experts fanned out across 12 counties in six of North Korea's nine provinces. They spoke with local farmers and officials. They visited grain stores and nursery schools. Zappacosta says he was struck by what North Koreans told him they were eating.

ZAPPACOZTA: Rice with limited quantities of maize and some vegetables during the period vegetables are available.

KUHN: In winter, many North Koreans don't really have any vegetables other than kimchi, a spicy, fermented cabbage dish. They're not getting enough protein. Meat, eggs and fish are a rare treat often available only on holidays - or even enough calories.

ZAPPACOZTA: And in some areas where they just depend on potatoes, they just eat potato. There is a really poor and monotonous diet. This was really remarkable.

KUHN: The survey concluded that North Korea is facing its worst harvest in a decade. As a result, more than 10 million North Koreans or about 40% of the population face food shortages. That's not nearly as bad as the mid-1990s, when up to 3.5 million people starved to death. But the survey did find that the country will have a shortage of just over a million metric tons of food.

ZAPPACOZTA: We may be somehow wrong slightly up or down. But the order of magnitude - we're quite confident.

KUHN: The poor harvests are due, in part, to bad weather - record droughts in some places and flooding in others. And although international sanctions are aimed at the North's military not civilians, they make it hard to get machine parts and gas needed for efficient mechanized farming.

ZAPPACOZTA: With the reduced availability of fuel, we saw people using oxen but also doing by hand.

KUHN: Last week, South Korea approved $8 million in food and medicine for aid agencies to distribute in North Korea. South Korean Unification Minister Kim Yeon-chul told reporters last week that the aid does not violate any sanctions. But Benjamin Katzeff Silberstein, co-editor of the blog NKEconwatch, says that $8 million worth of food is not going to make much difference. He argues that the food shortages are less about how much food is produced than about how it's distributed. And the distribution, he says, favors politically loyal elites in Pyongyang.

BENJAMIN KATZEFF SILBERSTEIN: North Korea's food shortages really aren't about - they're not about external shocks from the weather or from sanctions. They're about a system. That's it.

KUHN: It's also about the government's spending priorities, Silberstein argues. Despite the food shortages, Pyongyang has enough money for vanity projects like beach and ski resorts and, of course, weapons systems.

KATZEFF SILBERSTEIN: Well, if you can manufacture nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles, clearly, you can import enough food to make up for the shortfall in the harvest. There is no doubt about it.

KUHN: Silberstein notes that international donors have been giving North Korea food aid since the late 1990s. Aid groups don't want to let people starve, regardless of the North Korean government's choices. But as long as Pyongyang puts off necessary reforms to its system, he says, the shortages will continue.

Anthony Kuhn, NPR News, Seoul. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.