Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Syracuse Diocese explains decision to extend Rev. Fred Daly’s retirement six more months

Solar panels atop a church building with All Saints parish Center sign in front
Photo provided
Catholic Diocese of Syracuse decides to extend Rev. Daly's scheduled retirement six more months after discussions with parishoners.

Parishioners at All Saints Catholic Church were shocked by the Diocese of Syracuse’s initial decision to retire their longtime pastor, the Rev. Fred Daley, effective in January.

The diocese has since revised its plans, allowing Daley to remain in the role alongside the Rev. John Manno through June 2027.

The original decision came after Bishop Douglas Lucia accepted Daley’s retirement letter as part of a broader reorganization of parish leadership affecting 19 communities and 13 priests, the diocese said.

Parishioners at All Saints and St. Lucy’s said the announcement departed from an earlier arrangement that would have allowed Daley to serve both communities while helping develop a collaborative initiative known as the Costello Project.

Some parishioners also questioned whether the decision was connected to Daley’s ministry and a Sept. 28 voter-registration event at All Saints featuring Democratic U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

Danielle Cummings, the diocese’s chancellor and director of communications, said the changes were intended to address the diocese’s broader pastoral needs.

“The headlines and stories look like we moved one priest, when actually this is part of major pastoral changes that are taking place,” Cummings said.

Why the diocese chose Manno

The bishop’s decision to accept several retirement letters this year affected parishes throughout the diocese.

Under Catholic canon law, pastors are requested to submit a letter of resignation to their bishop at age 75, and the bishop decides whether to accept or defer it (Code of Canon Law, Can. 538 §3, Vatican). Daley, 79, submitted his at 75, and the diocese also has a policy that priests may no longer serve in an administrative role as a parish priest after turning 80, Cummings said.

Daley had led All Saints for 18 years. The diocese also accepted the resignation of the Rev. Francis Wapen, 83, who, like Daley, submitted his letter at age 75.

The decision coincided with the planned January retirement of the Rev. James Mathews, longtime pastor of St. Lucy’s. Cummings said that retirement and the Costello Project helped shape the leadership changes for the two parishes.

The proposed project involves All Saints, St. Lucy’s and four other organizations. It aims to strengthen the Catholic Church’s ministry among poor and marginalized communities, particularly in Syracuse’s inner city. It is named for the late Auxiliary Bishop Thomas Costello.

Cummings said Manno, who was completing his 12th year as pastor of Holy Family Church in Fairmount, had approached Bishop Lucia about working in the inner city. With Mathews retiring, the bishop saw an opportunity to appoint a younger priest who could guide the project from its inception and provide longer-term leadership, rather than subject the parishes to another transition when Daley retired, she said.

Manno, 51, also has inner-city ministry experience, including work with people experiencing homelessness through the Emmaus Ministry and at Oxford Street Inn.

“His heart is in serving the inner city,” Cummings said.

Lucia also saw an opportunity to expand the project to include St. Anthony’s on Calvin and Midland avenues and the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception, Cummings said.

What parishioners expected

David Pasinski, a St. Lucy’s parishioner who has known Daley since they met in seminary in 1966, said parishioners believed a different arrangement had been approved at a Sept. 21 meeting with the bishop. Under that plan, Daley would serve as administrator of St. Lucy’s while remaining pastor of All Saints through June, so the two parishes could keep planning the Costello Project together. An All Saints bulletin published the following weekend also described the arrangement.

Pasinski, who serves on St. Lucy’s board of trustees and transition team, said parishioners had welcomed the plan and begun preparing. The Nov. 5 announcement came as a surprise.

Pasinski said one concern was the hurt to All Saints of losing its pastor in eight weeks rather than eight months. He also pointed to the limited time Daley had to plan for retirement.

Michael DeSalvo, an All Saints parishioner, said the congregation had been preparing for Daley’s eventual retirement, but objected to the circumstances surrounding the decision.

“We had just celebrated our 18th anniversary and were really feeling great about the future and joining in with St. Lucy’s. It felt like the rug just got pulled out from everyone,” DeSalvo said.

He said the diocese’s explanations overlooked the contributions of those who had spent time developing the Costello Project.

“There were a lot of people that worked on this, and Father Fred certainly was a key person in all of it. The church, sadly, is acting like a corporation,” DeSalvo said.

Pasinski said he believed Lucia’s goal of continuity was sincere, but questioned whether other factors may also have influenced the decision.

Questions about the motive and timing

Some parishioners also wondered whether Daley’s public advocacy and ministry played a role. The parish has organized support for LGBTQ+ Catholics, immigrants and refugees through groups such as its LGBTQ+ Task Force and Refugee Welcoming Task Force. Daley publicly came out as a gay priest in 2004.

Cummings acknowledged parishioners’ pride in All Saints’ welcoming environment but said those commitments extend throughout the diocese.

“Most parishes serve the poor and help the marginalized and are welcoming. That is the sum and substance of who we should be. They may not all do it the same way, and that’s what makes the Catholic Church just a wonderful fabric because we are a universal church,” Cummings said.

Pasinski defended Daley’s record.

“Fred has always been an advocate in the prophetic mode in social justice teachings of the church, and sometimes they’ve conflicted with some of the powers that be, secular and religious,” Pasinski said.

He pointed to Daley’s support for LGBTQ+ communities but said Daley generally grounded his advocacy in Catholic social teaching rather than partisan politics.

Cummings rejected the suggestion that the decision was politically motivated.

“If this was political, it would have happened 18 years ago,” she said.

Those questions centered on a Sept. 28 political event at All Saints featuring U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

Cummings said the event violated diocesan policy, which prohibits politicians from speaking inside a church or on church property, regardless of political affiliation.

“It doesn’t matter if you’re a Democrat, Republican, Independent,” Cummings said. “These activities are not allowed in our churches.”

The bishop spoke with Daley after the event, Cummings said, and Daley understood that it had violated the policy.

“That does not mean that the decision to accept his retirement letter was in response to that behavior,” Cummings said. She reiterated that the decision was driven by the diocese’s long-term goal of establishing leadership for the Costello Project.

Pasinski said he was present when Daley apologized to the parish and called the event a serious error in judgment.

Pasinski said he respected Cummings but found it hard to believe the political event had no bearing. He said he believes complaints played a role in the decision, though he could not verify how many the diocese received. [Diocese response on complaints.]

Parishioners respond to revised plan

The initial announcement prompted an outpouring of concern. Some parishioners gathered for a prayer vigil at All Saints while Lucia met with parish representatives and staff from All Saints and St. Lucy’s.

Pasinski attended the meeting, which he said included about 40 people and lasted nearly two hours. He described Lucia as receptive to the concerns raised.

Under the revised arrangement announced Nov. 13, Daley and Manno will serve as co-pastors of All Saints from Jan. 2 through June 30, 2027. Manno will also serve as pastor of St. Lucy’s during that period. Daley is scheduled to retire at the end of the arrangement.

Cummings said the arrangement lets Daley stay at All Saints without changing Manno’s appointment. The bishop also allowed Wapen to remain in ministry until June.

Pasinski called the revised plan a compromise. He said it was not everything parishioners had hoped for but credited the bishop with listening.

“The message of hope is to celebrate the fact that their voices were heard,” Pasinski said.

DeSalvo said the parish would allow Manno to lead, while expecting him to respect and support the community.

“If Fred wants us to keep fighting, we’re gonna keep fighting. If he doesn’t, then we will give Father Manno an opportunity, and we’ll welcome him, but he has to also understand what he’s walking into,” DeSalvo said. “If he truly wants to come there, then we’ll accept him, but he needs to also accept us for who we are and really, really continue to support what’s going on in our parish.”

Cummings urged parishioners to avoid personal attacks and treat one another with respect, including in online discussions. DeSalvo said he did not hate the bishop and would be willing to sit down and talk with him.

“We’ve learned that it’s important to talk together. The bishop has to listen and we have to be open to respond both,” Pasinski said. He added that moving forward would require everyone to “speak boldly, listen with humility,” even when they cannot agree.

Evan Fay is an award-winning journalist at WAER. His most recent work has garnered first and second-place awards on both regional and national levels in medical, religion, science and technology, and political and cultural issues.