With New York’s 2027 legislative session approaching, advocates gathered in downtown Syracuse Tuesday to urge lawmakers to reconsider three bills that could change how long people spend in prison.
The rally at the CUSE Recovery Center was one of 8 held simultaneously across New York as part of the Communities Not Cages Campaign. Formerly incarcerated individuals, families and local officials called for changes in how prison sentences are determined, reviewed and potentially reduced.
The three proposals, known as the Second Look Act, Earned Time Act and Marvin Mayfield Act, have not passed the state legislature. Each addresses a different aspect of sentencing, with supporters arguing the changes would give greater consideration to rehabilitation and individual circumstances.
Another chance to have sentences reviewed
The Second Look Act would allow people serving lengthy sentences to ask a judge to reconsider their sentence after serving a set period. The judge could consider behavior in prison and participation in rehabilitation programs when deciding whether or not to shorten an individual’s sentence.
Armond Perry, a former inmate and member of the Center for Community Alternatives, said the proposal would give people a chance to show how they have changed.
“It's really about the things you have done to improve over the course of time,” Perry said.
According to court documents, Perry pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in a fatal shooting. A 2005 appeals court decision upheld his conviction and found that his sentence was not too harsh under the law.
Perry said the court did not give enough weight to his efforts to change when he sought release from prison.
Syracuse resident Julie Sams said the bill could also affect her brother, Alfred Robinson, who has spent 24 years in prison serving a sentence of 35 years to life.
Sams said her brother has earned a degree, studied law and helped other people while incarcerated.
“My brother is not the same 26-year-old who went to prison,” Sams said.
The bill would not guarantee anyone’s release. Judges would still decide whether to change a sentence.
Other proposals focus on reducing sentences
The Earned Time Act would expand programs that allow people in prison to earn time off their sentences through good behavior and activities such as education and job training.
The Marvin Mayfield Act would remove rules that require judges to impose a minimum sentence for certain crimes. This would give them more freedom to decide sentences on a case-by-case basis.
The proposed changes have raised concerns about public safety and the rights of crime victims. Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond Tierney has opposed the Second Look and Earned Time acts, arguing that they could allow some people convicted of serious violent crimes to leave prison earlier.
Crystal Leonard, who spoke at Tuesday’s rally, shared her experience as a survivor of violent crime. Leonard said one of her brothers died after being beaten, resulting in nine people being sent to prison.
“These bills don't erase what happened. They say a sentence should bend toward who a person has become, not just the worst night of their life,” Leonard said.
Supporters are now looking toward the incoming state Legislature for further action.
Assembly member-elect Maurice Brown, who will represent Syracuse's 129th Assembly District, announced at the rally that he plans to support all three bills when he takes office.