Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Onondaga County Sheriff Toby Shelley prepares for a second term

Onondaga County Sheriff Toby Shelley in his office Apr. 11, 2024.
Scott Willis
/
WAER News
Onondaga County Sheriff Toby Shelley in his office Apr. 11, 2024.

Onondaga County Sheriff Toby Shelley admits he wasn’t sure what to expect when he took office four years ago even after seeking the job four times. Now he’s preparing for his second term and says there’s still plenty of leftover business and new challenges to tackle. Shelley’s office is planning major steps toward consolidating jail operations in Jamesville, taking delivery of a new helicopter, and working through labor and fleet issues. WAER’s Scott Willis caught up with Shelley as he looks back on progress made and what’s ahead:

SCOTT WILLIS:

What's been the most satisfying, or what might you count among your accomplishments in your first term?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Coming in under budget, fixing pistol permits right away, doing shakedowns of both jails that hadn't been done in five years, we did within the first 30 days. Keeping Jamesville open, significant achievement. Getting the aviation program, pushed in the future with the buying of the new helicopter. We have 6 unions here at the office and every one of them got a decent contract in our time here. Overlap in the patrol schedules. We never have a time in our county where we don't have a deputy on the street, where before there's a gap at shift change and we don't have that. And that's significant to the safety of the people of the county.

SCOTT WILLIS:

I imagine one of the lowest points had to be the line of duty death of Lieutenant Michael Hoosock. How are you and the department managing now more than two years later?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

That's just a wound that doesn't heal. It never will heal. For those of us, especially those of us that remember Hooch, he was just a great person. Every time we go to another ceremony, it's just another thing that kind of pulls that scab off a little bit. I mean, we have to do those things, but it's just no easy way to ever heal on that one.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Are there any changes the department made after his death to help deputies and others get through that grief?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Yeah, we now have a full-time wellness person. Started out with a grant from then-Senator Mannion. The grant didn't get renewed, but we've continued to invest in that person who's investing in our people.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Does that seem to be helping?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

It's hard to gauge because a lot of the work our wellness person does, it's confidential. I might get a snippet of what's going on, but we send a lot of people her way.

SCOTT WILLIS:

What other challenges have you faced, anticipated or unexpected, internally or externally?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Yeah, this downtown union has been a significant challenge for us. The Deputy Sheriff's Benevolent Association, which represents the deputies in the Justice Center, the union president there has filed more grievances in a year than all the other unions combined in four years.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Do you have any idea what the source of these grievances is?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

So that's a good question. I have this alleged vote of no confidence, which I really question the validity of it. But when I ask some people that aren't happy here, what do you want? I mean, you're not happy for a reason, right? This is where other sheriffs, in my opinion, failed with this downtown union. They got frustrated and walked away. I've said to my administration, we need to walk towards these people and try and change their minds about whatever is making them unhappy. I will keep working to that end.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Where do things stand now?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

So we're going to start with a long list of 20-something things I have it over at my desk, of things I've done for the people at that jail. Something as simple as they [corrections officers] now with a permit can have their cell phones with them. The previous administration wouldn't allow them to even have their cell phones. Our information officer is going to start working on internal communications. I think it's something that we can do a better job on because a lot of people get disgruntled over something they really don't know the facts about. So we're going to try and get better at getting information out to people.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Your opponent raised the issue of department morale during the campaign and you raised the same issue under the previous sheriff when you ran four years ago. What have you done to improve morale and how would you characterize it since you took office?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Yeah, so the number one sign of poor morale is high sick leave. And the number one way to improve morale, believe it or not, is suggestion boxes. That's right out of my master's program. It's on civil service test to make rank. Immediately four years ago, we put in the suggestion boxes, and they're throughout the office. They're anonymous. They get collected once a month. I read every one of those. Most of them I give to the various chiefs of the different divisions to answer those questions.

But every single person here can have an anonymous voice in how to make the place better. So you can't tell me that you can't get to the sheriff. We have an open door policy where you can get to me through my secretary or you can go through the information officer, you can go through our wellness officer. And if it's a personal problem that you don't want your chief to know about, you can get to me. I listen to people. I listen to my command staff. I listen to the deputy at the ground level. So we're good listeners, but you got to tell us what's going on.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Consolidating Jamesville and downtown jails became a hot topic over the past four years. The county executive recently reversed his position and expressed a desire to combine the jails in Jamesville, which you favored all along. What's the status of the exploratory committee formed to take a deeper dive into that merger?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Our downtown jail is 30 years old on the outside. It's 130 years old on the inside. It's like a car that nickel and dimes you that you would eventually be like, I'm just getting a different car. And that's where we're at with that downtown jail. Jamesville doesn't have those issues. There's a lot of opportunity at Jamesville, the 100 acres. If you have a good vision for Jamesville, we could do a lot up there and have a sheriff's campus with our training and our headquarters and our jails and really make it a nice place. That takes money. So we have to bond out and everything.

It's got a few challenges, like you'd have to attach your jail to a courthouse so we could do arraignments. It's not an original idea of my office by any means because Oneida County is doing the same thing and it works well. Does it make some judges unhappy? Absolutely. Does it make other judges really happy? Yes, because they don't have to come downtown to arraignment. So it's a balancing act with some of the judges. We've had some conversations.

We got to talk to Centro to get the bus line to come to Jamesville for the inmates' families to come see them.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Has there been progress with the county executive's office on this front?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

So we've had some initial meetings. I detailed the chief and lieutenant to do some designs to build from. This is a dream building we'd like. This is what we can afford. We have done a lot of that work. The county executive has devoted a half million to explore this project, and that should generate some results.

SCOTT WILLIS:

What other priorities are on your plate for the next four years that you maybe didn't get to in your first four?

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Yeah, this struggle to get our fleet in a better position. When I get offered five cars and the city of Syracuse gets 55 cars, our operation is mobile. We can't operate without vehicles. I'd like to get the fleet in a good position where we're operating safe vehicles. I have patrol cars out there with 150,000 miles on them. I've got vehicles that are rusting out. My maintenance budget is higher, a lot higher than my budget to buy vehicles. And if I had a better fleet where I was rotating like 80,000 miles where they still had value in trade, eventually my maintenance budget would come down, which would fund the cost of buying the vehicles so I could make the 80,000 rotation. And that's what I'm trying to do. And I think ultimately if I can get the startup money to make that fleet like that, I can save the taxpayers money and have a better fleet.

SCOTT WILLIS:

Well, Sheriff Shelley, thanks so much for talking with us.

SHERIFF SHELLEY:

Thanks for coming in.

Scott Willis covers politics, local government, transportation, and arts and culture for WAER. He came to Syracuse from Detroit in 2001, where he began his career in radio as an intern and freelance reporter. Scott is honored and privileged to bring the day’s news and in-depth feature reporting to WAER’s dedicated and generous listeners. You can find him on twitter @swillisWAER and email him at srwillis@syr.edu.